Disclaimer: I am not a financial advisor, the info on this site is for educational purposes. All investing decisions should be based on your own research. Opinions expressed here are my personal views and should not be taken as financial advice.
Cosigning a loan for family might seem like a simple favor, but it can come with serious financial risks. In this situation, a young woman is being pressured to help her parents borrow $85,000, even though her fiancé is strongly against it.
Kaylie, 24, Texas
My parents want me to cosign an $85,000 loan on their house, and I honestly don’t understand why my fiancé is making such a big deal about it. My dad says it’s just a formality and that I won’t actually have to pay anything. But my fiancé, Brandon, says I’m making a huge mistake and has even threatened to call off our wedding if I go through with it.
I’m 24 years old, and I work as a receptionist at a dental office. I make about $43,000 a year, and Brandon and I have been saving to buy our first house. We have almost $18,000 saved between us, and we’re hoping to start looking at houses next summer. My parents know how hard we’ve worked to save that money, but Dad says helping them with this loan shouldn’t affect our plans.
My parents have always been good to me. They helped pay for college, let me live at home rent-free until I was 22, and even helped me buy my first car. Dad brings those things up whenever we talk about the loan. He says he never expected me to pay him back for raising me, but he thought he could at least count on me when he needed help. I feel terrible because he’s right about how much they’ve done for me.
A few weeks ago, my parents invited me over for dinner. After we ate, Dad explained that they were trying to borrow money against their house, but the bank wouldn’t approve them because of some problems with his credit. He said he’d missed a few credit card payments last year and that having someone with better credit cosign would solve everything. He told me I was their best option because my younger brother doesn’t have a steady job and my mom’s credit isn’t much better than his.
When I asked what the $85,000 was for, Dad said they needed a new roof and wanted to pay off some bills. He also mentioned that he and Mom were hoping to take a trip to Hawaii for their 30th anniversary. They’ve wanted to go for years, and I thought it was nice that they might finally get the chance. Dad said they deserved something after working hard their whole lives, and I agree with him.
I asked whether I’d be responsible for any payments, and Dad said absolutely not. He told me the bank just needed my signature and that he would handle everything else. He even said I probably wouldn’t hear anything about the loan again after signing. Since he’s always managed our family’s finances, I figured he understood how these things work better than I do.
Later that night, I told Brandon about it, and he got really upset. He wanted to know why my parents needed to borrow so much money and why the bank wouldn’t approve them without me. When I explained the situation, he said that cosigning meant I could be responsible for the entire $85,000 if my parents stopped making payments. I told him that wasn’t going to happen, but he said nobody plans to stop paying their bills.
He also said the loan could make it harder for us to qualify for our own mortgage next year. I tried explaining that I wouldn’t actually be making the payments, but he said lenders might still count the debt against me. We ended up arguing for almost an hour, and he finally said he wouldn’t marry someone who was willing to take on that much debt without understanding what she was signing. I thought that was a really hurtful thing to say.
The next morning, I called Mom because I was upset. She said Brandon was trying to control me and that I shouldn’t let a man come between me and my family. Dad was disappointed too. He said he’d never imagined his own daughter would hesitate to help him after everything he’d sacrificed for her. He also mentioned that they were counting on me because they’d already told the contractor they could get the roof fixed soon.
A couple of days later, Dad called and told me something he hadn’t mentioned before. Apparently, they have about $27,000 in credit card debt, and part of the loan would be used to pay that off. He said the cards had gotten out of control because of expenses over the years, including things they bought for me when I was younger. He explained that combining everything into one payment would save them money, which sounded reasonable.
He also asked me not to tell Brandon about the credit cards. He said Brandon already had a negative opinion of them and would only use the information against our family. I agreed because I don’t think Brandon needs to know every detail of my parents’ finances. Dad also said that if I really trusted my family, I wouldn’t need to discuss the loan with anyone else.
I’ve been trying to come up with a way to make everyone happy. I suggested that Dad put something in writing saying he and Mom would make all the payments. He said he’d be happy to do that, although he seemed a little offended that I would even ask. He also promised that after a year or two, once his credit improves, he’ll have my name removed from the loan.
Yesterday, Dad asked whether I could send him my last two pay stubs and a copy of my bank statement. He also wanted to know how much Brandon and I had saved for our house. When I told him about the $18,000, he suggested temporarily moving the money into an account with only my name on it so the bank could see that I had plenty of savings. He said we could move it right back afterward. I haven’t mentioned that part to Brandon because I know he’ll say no.
Mom called again this morning and said Dad has barely been sleeping because he’s worried about losing the loan. She said she doesn’t want to pressure me, but she also doesn’t understand why I’m making things so difficult when all they need is a signature. She reminded me that families are supposed to help each other and said she hopes I’ll remember that when they’re older and need someone to take care of them.
I’m supposed to meet Dad at the bank on Friday. I’ve decided that I’ll probably go ahead and sign because I don’t want to let my parents down. I haven’t told Brandon yet, and I’m thinking it might be easier to explain everything after it’s done. My mom says he’ll get over it eventually if he really loves me.
I know Brandon thinks I’m being naive, but I can’t imagine my parents would ever put me in a bad financial situation on purpose. Dad says the bank wouldn’t approve the loan if it was actually dangerous for me, and I have to believe he knows what he’s talking about. I’m just hoping this doesn’t cause problems when Brandon and I apply for our own mortgage next year.
5 Reasons Cosigning a Loan for Family Can Be a Bad Idea
Cosigning a loan for a family member can create financial problems that last for years. Even when you trust the person borrowing the money, you’re taking on a legal responsibility that shouldn’t be treated as a simple favor.
1. You’re responsible for the entire loan
When you cosign a loan, you agree to repay the debt if the primary borrower doesn’t. It doesn’t matter whether you received any of the money or whether your family member promised to make every payment. If they stop paying, the lender can hold you responsible for the remaining balance under the loan agreement.
2. It could prevent you from buying your own house
Mortgage lenders consider your existing debts when determining how much you can afford to borrow. A cosigned loan may be included in your debt-to-income ratio, even when someone else makes the payments. Some mortgage programs allow certain cosigned debts to be excluded when specific requirements are met, but you shouldn’t assume that will happen.
3. A written agreement doesn’t remove your responsibility
Having your parents sign a document promising to make the payments doesn’t change your obligations to the lender. Unless the lender formally releases you from the loan, you’re still responsible for the debt. A private agreement cannot simply override the loan contract.
4. Getting your name removed may be difficult
Cosigners generally can’t remove themselves from a loan whenever they want. The borrower may need to refinance into a new loan or qualify for a formal cosigner release if the lender offers one. If the borrower still has poor credit or insufficient income, removing your name could be difficult or impossible without paying off the debt.
5. Your credit and savings could be at risk
Late payments on a cosigned loan can damage your credit history. If the borrower defaults, you could face collection efforts, legal action, and potentially a judgment against you. Cosigning doesn’t necessarily require you to hand over your savings, but it creates a financial obligation that could eventually put those savings at risk.
Helping family members financially isn’t always a bad decision, but cosigning a large loan should never be treated as a harmless favor. Before signing, make sure you understand the full obligation, can afford to repay the debt yourself if necessary, and have reviewed the terms independently.
💡 Explore our free financial tools:
- Salary increase calculator – see how a raise will impact your paycheck or annual income.
- Compound interest calculator – see how small investments grow over time.
- Debt payoff calculator – find out how long it takes to pay off your debt and what it’ll cost you.
- Subscription savings calculator – uncover the true cost of forgotten subscriptions.
- Student loan payoff calculator – plan student debt payments that fit your budget.
- Retirement investment calculator – check if your savings plan supports your retirement goals.
- Emergency fund calculator – learn how much cash to keep aside for peace of mind.
- Impulse buy calculator – double-check if those purchases are really worth it.
- Mortgage refinance calculator – see how refinancing could lower payments or save interest.
- Mortgage affordability calculator – find out how much house you can afford with your budget.